Good argument ó e.g., takes seriously possible objections
Completion of all aspects of the assignment
Displays original thought ó i.e., is not merely an articulate
restatement of either the reading or class discussion. Original does not mean
an entirely new argument never before thought of. Originality may
include bringing in relevant material from other sections in class or other
classes. It may involve an original thought experiment to make a
point. Etc..
"B" GRADE:
Does all of the A GRADE requirements above but not as well (some minor flaws ó perhaps not as original, not as clear, etc.)
"C" GRADE:
Does the assignment and does not obviously misunderstand crucial elements
But either no demonstration of complete and clear understanding
of any of the elements of the assignment or argument does not take the opposing view seriously
[The difference between a B GRADE and a C GRADE turns on the number of minor flaws]
"D" GRADE:
Fundamental misunderstanding of article or issue
OR
Very poorly written ó paper filled with grammatical errors.
"F" GRADE:
Shows no understanding of argument
OR
Does not follow assignment. Quality of work is irrelevant
in this case
OR
Plagiarized portion of paper
If you are unclear regarding the nature of plagiarism, find and read
the following WWW sites: