The following individuals have been recognized as recipients of the Madelyn Levitt Award for Mentoring. Names link to biographies of the recipients.
| 1994 | Wanda E. Everage Assistant to the Provost for Academic Enhancement |
| 1995 | Margie M. Davidson Assistant to the Dean for Student Services, Arts and Sciences |
| 1996 | Robert D. Woodward Professor, Journalism & Mass Communication |
| 1997 | Lon Larson Associate Professor of Pharmacy Administration |
| 1998 | Nivedita K. Pandit Associate Professor of Pharmaceutic |
| 1999 | Mary S. Edrington Assistant Dean/Internship Coordinator, College of Business and Public Administration |
| 2000 | Julian P. Archer Professor of History |
| 2001 | Alexander F. Kleiner, Jr. Thomas Sheehan Professor of Math and Computer Science |
| 2002 | Darrel Bjornson Associate Professor of Pharmacy Administration |
| 2003 | Carol Spaulding-Kruse Associate Professor of English |
| 2004 | John Rozycki Associate Professor of Finance |
| 2005 | Jean Berger Associate Athletic Director |
| 2006 | Eleanor Zeff Assistant Professor of Politics |
| 2007 | Lon Larson Ellis and Nelle Levitt Professor of Pharmacy Administration |
| 2008 | Geoffrey Wall Associate Professor of Pharmacy Practice |
| 2009 | Jennifer Harvey Assistant Professor of Religion |
| 2010 | Carol Spaulding-Kruse Associate Professor of English |
| 2011 | Gholam Mirafzal Professor of Chemistry |
| 2012 | Linda Krypel Professor of Pharmacy Practice |
| 2013 | John Lytle Professor of Journalism/ Ellis and Nelle Levitt Distinguished Professor |