The following individuals have been recognized as recipients of the Madelyn Levitt Award for Teaching. Names link to biographies of the recipients
| 1994 | Barbara C. Hodgdon Ellis & Nelle Levitt Professor of English |
| 1995 | Alexander F. Kleiner, Jr. Sheehan Professor of Mathematics and Computer Science |
| 1996 | Robert C. Hunter Professor of Law |
| 1997 | James Reynolds Professor of Pharmacology |
| 1998 | Nancy C. Reincke Associate Professor of English |
| 1999 | Patricia Prijatel Professor, Journalism and Mass Communication |
| 2000 | Daniel T. Spencer Associate Professor of Religion |
| 2001 | Donald Stratton Professor of Biology/Ellis & Nelle Levitt Distinguished Professor of Physiology |
| 2002 | Jody Swilky Associate Professor of English |
| 2003 | Mark Vitha Assistant Professor of Chemistry |
| 2004 | Fred Adams Ellis & Nelle Levitt Professor of History |
| 2005 | Steven Faux Associate Professor of Psychology |
| 2006 | Leanne Freeman-Miller Associate professor of Voice |
| 2007 | Stuart Klugman Principal Financial Group Distinguished Professor of Actuarial Science |
| 2008 | James Dodd Aliber Professor of Accounting |
| 2009 | Laurie Doré Ellis & Nelle Levitt Distinguished Professor of Law |
| 2010 | Rachel Paine Caufield Associate Professor of Politics |
| 2011 | Keith Summerville Associate Professor of Environmental Science |
| 2012 | Patrick Heaston Aliber Distinguished Professor of Accounting |
| 2013 | Mary Edrington Associate Professor of Practice in Marketing |